Sometimes our children bring challenges that we don’t expect when we dream of sweet, soft babies and sloppy kisses. Who ever dreams of having to put restrictions on the two year old they have come to call the Smack-Talking Baby? Sweet…check. Soft…check. Sloppy kisses…check. Smack-talk? I mean, really?
Aidan is a literalist. Though he gets jokes now, for a long time we had to explain exactly why jokes were funny. Not easy, by the way, and we are thankful that we had a professor in college who was semi-obsessed about deconstructing funny.
So when Emerson came along, his grandfather was thrilled to have a grandson he could tease in a way that Aidan did not like. Aidan was good for building and getting really excited about projects, but he was frequently bewildered by some of his granddad’s colloquialisms. As a grandfather, Patrick’s father is somewhat boisterous and full of bon amie. “Emerson Boy,” he might say, “If you don’t stop tickling me, I’m gonna skin you alive and make a wallet out of you!”
And Emerson eats it up.
Emerson was an early talker and it soon became apparent that he had inherited the gene that allowed him to give as good as he got from Granddaddy. He would be silent in the car, as we approached my in-laws’ house. Upon arrival he would run in and gleefully rip off whatever charming little gem he’d been working up in the car. “Granddaddy, I’m going to cut you up in pieces and put you in the crock pot and EAT YOU!”
Did I say charming, or disturbing?
“REALLY!” we would gasp, completely scandalized but somehow laughing all the same.

It was the laughing that did us in, of course. You can’t laugh at a child like Emerson and then expect that his shocking behavior will do anything but continue. But it was so clever! And how hysterical to hear such things come out of such a little boy! We knew we shouldn’t laugh, but we were nearly helpless to stop.
We would be at Wendy’s and Emerson would cheerfully offer to run Wendy through with a sword because the counter girl had forgotten the sour cream for my baked potato. The poor, harmless geriatric couple at the next table would look our way in horror. What in heavens are they teaching that child?
Sometimes I wanted to look back at them, with the same horrified expression mirrored on my face, and whisper, “Did YOU teach my child to say that??” I wished they had. I could have spanked them and been done with it.
Though, in fairness, his gruesome commentary was not just for the people around him. Sometimes it was simply a part of his narrative.
One afternoon, I took the boys to the bank to make their monthly savings deposit. They got the obligatory rummage in the bank “treasure chest” to pick out a prize. This particular month they had little, toddler-hand sized tote bags emblazoned with the bank’s logo. The boys were enchanted and spent the better part of a day plotting what they might put in their bags.
After a bit of grocery shopping at the Aldi, Emerson told Aidan and I the following plan he had devised.
“I will go to Aldi and buy a rabbit. I will put the rabbit in my bag and carry it home. When I get home, I will kill the rabbit and skin it and put it in the oven and cook it. Then I will eat it and hang the skull on my skull hook on my special shelf.”
Now, before you ask, yes, we did have a “special shelf” for each boy to place cherished belongings on, but NO, they were NOT equipped with “skull hooks”!
Skull hooks!?!!
Finally, Patrick and I decided that the looks of disapproval on strangers’ faces were more distressing then Emreson’s bon mots were funny. I mean, we agreed that it wasn’t at all appropriate for a not-quite-two year old to be speaking so disturbingly and disrespectfully. So Patrick engineered one the best rules that he, who is an excellent rule-maker, has made to date. “Emerson,” he declared, “You must stop smack-talking everyone and everything. It just isn’t appropriate for a little boy to say such things all the time. From now on, you may only smack-talk Granddaddy and bonafide enemies of the USA.”
It was brilliant! We still got to enjoy the gruesome creativity that only an Emerson can exhibit, but could avoid convincing other parents that they needed to keep an eye on our son, lest he get too close to one of their children. This would seriously restrict his opportunity to shock and horrify. Honestly, Emerson wasn’t even aware that the US HAD enemies!
Until his father joined the Army. “Why does Daddy have to be away from us?” he asked me, the night we dropped Patrick off at the hotel, from where he would ship out to Basic Training the next morning. There had been lots of Army talk at our house in the past weeks, as one might imagine. Aidan had even determined to start his own private army, the American Sharks.
I reminded Emerson that Daddy was learning how to fight bad people who wanted to fight our country. Enemies, if you will, of the US. Emerson thought about for a moment, and then announced the plan that would render the need for Daddy to fight, obsolete. “I will cook them in the oven like chicken nuggets and feed them to the American Sharks for a snack,” he declared.
An excellent idea, I agreed.